Toplist vs AtComet

Dear all, one of our friends in this forum made a suggestion about the “Torrent sites” section in BitComet v1.19.

He suggested to replace the link in “Toplists of Torrent Sites” with http://toplist.bitcomet.com

Please let us know which site do you prefer, the original (http://www.atcomet.com/topic_p/torrent/?bcl) or the suggested (http://toplist.bitcomet.com). Thank you and please participate. :slight_smile:

The BitComet Team

scrn.PNG

My Vote goes to toplist.bitcomet.com because:

  1. This site is online since 2007 year

  2. I have founded many interesting torrent sites via toplist.bitcomet.com

  3. It was ( and it will be ) well , Google Pageranked ,

I’ve never had toplist respond to me with anything other than an error, usually ‘connection was reset while the page was loading’, so obviously, I don’t think it’s ready to be a replacement. I’ve never seen the site, just error messages.

As far as the AtComet list, the top-rated site is still Mininova, which was shut down except for content distribution since November. IOW it’s sadly out of date.

I’d have to go with “neither”.

kluelos hey mate :slight_smile: vote for toplist please :smiley:

My vote goes with the more eye friendly atcomet, but,as kluelos says it needs updating, and the downtimes we get complaints about don’t help.

It’s the first time I see toplist.bitcomet.com, no errors though..

Toplist has a bad reputation, maybe you don’t know about wot but its 300000000 users sure do.

A way for the users who use the favorites panel to add their own favorite sites to that list should be implemented.

I’m not ready to vote for a site I’ve never seen, and still can’t see.

Well, I can’t access it either (toplist.com). Therefore, thumbs down. :smiley:

Dear all, thank you for all those statements.

toplist has been fixed already, but seems like most of you don’t like it.

Since I know nothing about these 2 sites, and we all have our own preferences, I recgon the best solution may be Vasy’s suggestion about the favourite panel.

But we’ll see how the voting goes, see if there’ll be any surprises.

well if you hate ( for some reasons :slight_smile: ) toplist.bitcomet.com, my opinion is to do the next:

integrate all 2 sites in bitcomet :slight_smile: , and see what users will say

I, personally neither hate nor love it.

I just couldn’t access it for two days in a row now. That’s what I was giving it thumbs down for, and I believe that kluelos was stating the same in his last post.

5 days.

I’m with Vasy

Hey guys I’m just wondering here, those sites are opened by web browsers anyway, so what’s the difference of adding favourites to BC and to the web browser? :rolleyes:

Lucy I have sent e-mail with pics about toplist for you, please see them :slight_smile: I can’t enter the site :frowning:

Can someone from US or another country access toplist.bitcomet.com? I have asked my friends from Russia and US ( New York ) to visit toplist and they can’t do it

can someone confirm it? I can’t access it too

toplist continues to reset the connection whenever I try to access it.

I never saw any errors from http://toplist.bitcomet.com/ :blink: Maybe it’s on multiple servers…

/monthly_04_2010/post-53701-1272552569129.png" rel=“”>

I could never access it; not for a single time.

Ditto for today.

Yes it’s quite weird, because I can always access toplist from here, but some users in certain countries are not able to access it…

Thanks for the info :slight_smile: very strange